Player A says, "Wait wait wait, we left the tavern kinda quickly. What all did we take with us? Fluffy and Word need to take inventory."
Potion of Coloring Things Gold (2 doses remaining; lasts 6 hours)
Potion of Create Back Hair (3 sips remaining; permanent; only works on things with backs when ingested)
Potion of Banish Back Hair (3 sips remaining; permanent; only works on things with backs when ingested)
Potion of Reduce Weight 90% (2 doses remaining; lasts 6 minutes)
Apprentice Alchemist Leather Apron and Gloves + Clothes for Armor 1
Belt with Pouches to Hold Stuff
Normal Clothing for + Clean but damp do-rag for Armor 1
3 changes of socks and underwear, damp but clean
About 2 days worth of food, including dried fish, cured meat, berries, and carrots.
15 steel arrows
1 Silver Feather
Player B says, "Would it be mischievous of me to suggest that Word use a Potion of Create Back Hair on Walter?"
Player A says, "No, don't use the potion on Fluffy! You might find a use for it later, a dire one in which, but for the Back Hair Potion, all would have been lost.
"Okay, I think we need to really hunker down and discuss what to do here. This seems to be a major crossroad with lots of choices."
I say, "I approve of mischief. If you can make a plausible scene or description of Word getting Fluffy to drink it, then it will be so. You have to agree on your actions, so discuss amongst yourselves."